Comparing Performance in the Field
When it comes to dove and quail hunting, choosing the right shot material is as important as your gauge and choke. Lead has been the traditional go-to for decades, but steel shot has become more prevalent due to environmental regulations and availability. Both materials have their place in the upland fields, but understanding how they perform differently can help you choose the right load for the conditions you’ll face and the results you’re after. Pattern density significantly affects the performance of both lead and steel shot. Hunters using steel shot can bag just as many, if not more birds, compared to those using lead. Studies have shown no significant advantage of one type of shot over the other, effectively declaring it a draw in performance.
Lead Shot: Traditional, Dense, and Effective
Lead shot has long been preferred by upland hunters for its density and smooth patterns of lead pellets. Many hunters perceive shooting lead as more lethal and efficient due to its heavier weight, which allows smaller pellets to retain energy and penetrate cleanly, resulting in quick, ethical kills on small birds like doves and quail. Lead patterns tend to be more consistent, and recoil is often lighter for the same velocity compared to steel. The effectiveness of lead loads in open fields is particularly notable, allowing shooters to use smaller shot sizes like 7½ or 8 without sacrificing impact.
Steel Shot: Lighter but Still Capable
Steel is less dense than lead, so it requires larger pellets to deliver the same energy downrange. That typically means using shot sizes like #6 steel shot for dove and quail hunting when using steel. When properly matched in size and velocity, steel loads can be highly effective for hunting. Because the pellets are lighter, steel shot can lose energy more quickly, which affects performance at longer distances. That said, at typical upland hunting ranges—especially under forty yards—size 7 steel shot can still do the job effectively with proper shot placement. It’s also often the only legal option in areas near wetlands or other protected habitats.
Patterning and Choke Considerations
Because of the lighter nature of steel shot, patterns can behave differently compared to lead. Steel tends to pattern tighter, so some hunters opt for a more open choke than they would use with lead to compensate. If you’re used to shooting improved cylinder (ic) choke with lead, you might want to try cylinder or skeet with steel. Choke constrictions impact shot patterns and effectiveness with lead versus steel loads, so it's crucial to consider this when choosing your choke. Always pattern your shotgun with the specific load you plan to hunt with to see how it performs at your expected shooting distance.
Legal and Environmental Factors
Many public lands, national wildlife refuges, and water-adjacent hunting areas now require non-toxic shot, which makes steel the default choice in those locations. Lead poisoning is a significant environmental and health concern, prompting regulatory changes to transition to non-toxic alternatives like steel shot. While lead is still legal for upland hunting in many areas, it’s worth checking local regulations before heading out. From an environmental standpoint, steel is a safer option around water and sensitive habitats, where lead accumulation can impact birds and other wildlife. Additionally, using steel shot for hunting waterfowl and other game birds helps mitigate health risks to wildlife and humans, particularly children, who might ingest lead pellets.
Cost and Availability
Lead shot generally offers better performance and more shot per shell, but it’s increasingly limited in where it can be used. The Winchester Xpert Game & Target Steel Load is a popular choice among hunters, known for its effective performance and availability in various shot sizes like #6 and #7 steel. Steel, once considered a poor substitute, has improved considerably and is now more widely available and affordable than it once was. Specialty non-toxic options like bismuth and tungsten offer performance closer to lead but come at a higher price point. For most hunters, choosing between lead and steel comes down to access, legality, and shot preference, with many frequently purchasing boxes of lead shot for their hunts.
Making the Right Choice for the Hunt
If you’re hunting on private land where lead is legal and ethical considerations permit, lead remains a great choice for its consistent performance and kill power, as many hunters prefer. The skill and decisions of the person pulling the trigger are crucial in determining the success of the hunt.
In public land or areas with environmental restrictions, steel shot—properly selected and patterned—will still drop birds cleanly. Knowing your terrain, your expected shooting distances, and the rules of your hunting area should guide your decision. The goal, always, is a clean shot and a quick retrieve, and the individual holding the shotgun, whether it's a guy or a gal, significantly influences hunting success.
FAQs
Is lead or steel better for dove hunting?
Shooting lead typically performs better due to its density and pattern consistency compared to steel. However, shooting steel is still effective at close to moderate ranges when properly selected.
What shot size should I use with steel for doves or quail?
Shot sizes like 6 or 7 work well with steel, offering a balance between pellet count and energy retention. Various steel shot sizes are effective for hunting doves, with #6 shot being particularly notable. The performance of #6 shot for hunting doves is often highlighted due to its better energy retention and density, which can match the performance of lead loads at moderate distances.
Can I use lead shot on public land?
It depends on the location. Many public lands require non-toxic shot, so always check local regulations before hunting.
Efforts to educate hunters about the effectiveness of non-toxic steel pellets versus traditional lead pellets are ongoing. The results of this research will be utilized by the Texas Parks and Wildlife Department to help hunters understand their options when selecting shotshell loads for dove hunting.
Does steel shot damage my shotgun?
Modern shotguns are built to handle steel shot, but older guns with fixed chokes may not be rated for it. Check your firearm’s specifications.
What choke should I use with steel shot?
Steel tends to pattern tighter, so using a more open choke—like cylinder or skeet—can improve results at typical upland hunting distances.
Â